Thursday, December 18, 2014

DO AS I SAY, NOT AS I LEAK

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Chief Justice Ron Castille was troubled enough by Attorney General Kathleen Kane leaking information from a grand jury investigating the former Philadelphia NAACP leader Whyatt Mondesire that he authorized a special grand jury investigation into the matter.

Yet, it appears that Castille has leaked secret information about this new grand jury examining Kane:

“Chief Justice Ronald D. Castille told reporters that some of the documents in question constituted grand jury material, which would be confidential…. Questioned by reporters at the annual Pennsylvania Society gathering in New York, Castille countered that at least one of the documents that appeared in the Daily News story should have been confidential. ‘It was a detective's statement,’ said Castille, speaking to two reporters at the Metropolitan Club.” (Philadelphia Inquirer 12/14/14)

So, because of grand jury secrecy rules, there is a detective’s statement that Kane should not have provided the Daily News. If she is precluded from revealing it because it is secret, then how can Castille discuss it?

Furthermore, would not Castille’s revelation that the detective statement is at the center of the new grand jury investigation be a further violation of grand jury secrecy rules?

The law is incredibly clear that Castille is violating the law because discussing anything in a grand jury is verboten:

“All evidence, including exhibits and all testimony presented to the grand jury, is subject to grand jury secrecy, and no person may disclose any matter occurring before the grand jury, except…Defendant in a Criminal Case…[and] A grand jury witness may disclose his or her testimony”. (PA Code Rule 556.10)

We suppose that Castille could say that he is not violating the secrecy rules because he wasn’t sworn in as part of the Mondesire grand jury proceedings.  Fair enough, but that in turn raises further questions.

First, how much different would this excuse be than Kane’s for leaking information from the Mondesire grand jury:

“Reading prepared remarks, [Kane] acknowledged that her office had released information, but said it did so ‘in a way that did not violate statutory or case law regarding grand jury secrecy.’….’Nothing she said suggested in any way that she committed a crime - because she didn't commit a crime. She didn't cross any ethical line," said Gerald Shargel, a New York City criminal defense lawyer.” (Philadelphia Inquirer 11/19/14)

It sounds like Shargel’s interpretation of the law is based on his reading of Title 42 which seems to give Kane wiggle room from Rule 556.10 given that she was not part of the Mondesire grand jury, and consequently, not sworn into secrecy:

“a juror, attorney, interpreter, stenographer, operator of a recording device, or any typist who transcribes recorded testimony may disclose matters occurring before the grand jury only when so directed by the court. All such persons shall be sworn to secrecy, and shall be in contempt of court if they reveal any information which they are sworn to keep secret.” (Title 42 Subchapter D Section 4549)

If this interpretation also applies to Castille openly discussing that the detective’s statement was at the center of the grand jury investigating Kane, then who leaked to him the information that the detective’s statement was at the center of its investigation?

Who has the authority over the Chief Justice to authorize a grand jury to investigate the leaks from a grand jury that is investigating leaks from a grand jury?

13 comments:

Anonymous said...

Ugarte,
Thank you for pointing out the hypocrisy of the Chief Justice and the ever present "leaks" associated with Pennsylvania Grand Juries.

Castille inserted himself into a Grand Jury matter. Members of the legal community would be reprimanded for such actions.

In 2013, Supervisory Grand Jury Judge Barry Feudale received authorization to name a Special Prosecutor to investigate leaks in the Sandusky and DeNaples Grand Juries.

Feudale named two former associates of Frank Fina, Chief Prosecutor in the Office of Attorney General, to serve as Special Prosecutors. Fina was a prosecutor in the Sandusky investigation and trial.

Grand Jury secrecy prevented the Sandusky/DeNaples Grand Jury Leak Report from being made public. So who was protected?

Grand Juries in Pennsylvania are totally controlled by the prosecutor. Witnesses are selected and prepared by the prosecutor. Even the final Presentment is written by the Prosecutor.

The Montgomery County Grand Jury Special Prosecutor was authorized by Chief Justice Castille. Associated with the Grand Jury investigation is an Order preventing Frank Fina from being named by the Attorney General of the Commonwealth in any capacity. Strange?

It has been reported that Fina was actively involved in the pornographic email scandal that infiltrated the judiciary and the Office of the Attorney General.

Who is being protected at the expense of the Attorney General?
We need to hear the truth.

Anonymous said...

What does Fina have on people? The man has paralyzed the criminal justice system. We need an investigation of the cases left by Fina for Kane to fall into. Seems like the criticism has been orchestrated.

Anonymous said...

Ahah!

The investigation of Grand Jury leaks by the AG is Leaked by the Newspaper about previous leaks of Grand Jury testimony!

This is an Alice in Wonderland world of leaks about leaks and challenges not only the integrity of the present AG but of the entire process of Secrecy of Grand Juries after the decisions have been made!

The who replaces the why and we remain victims of political correctness instead of citizens being informed about the deeds of our police, courts, and other facets of our society after the decisions are made.

No wonder we have problems in Ferguson and other areas of deciding how to remedy our justice and enforcement systems.

Grand Juries are being used to set free Police, Prosecutors, and Judges from Indictments but then used to indict political opposition and private people for crimes controlled by Prosecutors that leak such details illegally?

Anonymous said...

The abuse discovered by an independent Grand Jury Special Prosecutor should be made public.

If Grand Jury secrecy is in place to protect the integrity of the Grand Jury, then illegal abuse of the Grand Jury system should be exposed.

Prosecutors stand to benefit from leaks. Court staff and Grand Jurors would be too frightened to talk to reporters.

Anonymous said...

All Media, Newspapers and Attorneys should be demanding the release of all Emails under Corbett-Kelly-Fina Prosecutors along with the many Judges (And There Are Many Not Just A Few) connected to the Illegal use of State Computers on State Time by these State Employees to be released to the Public under the Open Records Laws and go to Federal Court to cause their release right away.

In addition, a Grand Jury needs to be convene that brings Former AG Prosecutors Frank Fina, Blessington and Constanzo before them under oath on their own participations of Grand Jury Leaks, Selective Prosecutions, and Malicious Investigations violations under their tenure at the Attorney General Office where those practices by them including Porno emails actually occurred!

This is the kind of light that shines on Frank Fina's Gang of Secrecy with some Judges they are hiding behind in attacking AG Kane!

Anonymous said...

As an example of how common grand jury leaks are, you could have cited this grand jury.

We have known everything that is going on for months. Or you could have cited the statewide grand jury investigating bonusgate.

Where are the results of the investigation into the Grand Jury leaks in the Sandusky case?

Was the investigation ever completed?

I smell something fishy...follow the money...that went from The Second Mile Campaign Contributors to...Tom Corbett's Campaign?

The truth must come out and she needs to sustain the attacks. This is politics at its worst. In Pennsylvania, witnesses are allowed to discuss their Grand Jury testimony.

Why is AG Kane being threatened when Frank Fina leaked many Grand Jury Reports prior to his Indictments and not one Judge was upset about it?

Anonymous said...

The two Special Prosecutors in 2013 investigating the DeNaples and Sandusky Grand Juries were former Office of the Attorney General coworkers with Fina. Was the porno ring protecting the porno ring?

Anonymous said...

It is not the duty of the OAG to investigate District Attorneys. A complaint shoud be filed with the commonwealth court in the county the DA represents.(b) Upon complaint in writing, verified by oath or affirmation of the party aggrieved, made to the court in which any district attorney shall prosecute the pleas of the Commonwealth, charging such district attorney with wilful and gross negligence in the execution of the duties of his office, the court shall cause notice of such complaint to be given to the district attorney and of the time fixed by the court for the hearing of the same. If upon such hearing the court shall be of opinion that there is probable cause for the complaint, they shall hand over or commit the district attorney to answer the same in due course of law. If the court shall be of opinion that there is no probable cause for such complaint, they shall dismiss the same, with reasonable costs to be assessed by the court.

Section 1406. District Attorney Charged with Crime.--If any district attorney is charged, according to law, with any crime or misdemeanor, before or bound over or committed by any court to answer for wilful and gross negligence in the execution of the duties of his office, it shall be the duty of the court to appoint some competent attorney thereof to prepare an indictment against such district attorney and to prosecute the same on behalf of the Commonwealth until final judgment. Such attorney shall be paid by the county for his services a reasonable compensation to be fixed by the court. If such district attorney shall be convicted of any crime for which he may be sentenced to imprisonment by separate or solitary confinement at labor, his office shall be declared vacant by the court.

Anonymous said...

Judge Barry Feudale, Supervisor Judge for the Central PA state Grand Jury in 2013, asked Chief Justice Castille for permission to name a Special Prosecutor to investigate leaks in the Denaples and Sandusky Grand Juries.

Feudale named a Special Prosecutor and later an assistant Special Prosecutor. Both men were former co-workers of Frand Fina. OAG was investigating OAG. No report regarding the leaks was ever made public.

Is this the legal system protecting the citizens of PA? It appears the judiciary was helping the prosecutors.

Ciro Sciacqualaquaglia New York - Naples said...

1
Ho tantissimo da scrivere su sto Renato Vallanzasca misto ad Ugo Fantozzi della finanza piu' filo mafiosa, piu' ricicla soldi mafiosi, piu' Berlusco-nazista e Pada-nazista, che e' il verminoso avanzo di galera, gia' 3 volte finito in carcere: criminalissimo Paolo Barrai, nato a Milano il 28.06.1965. Lo faro' gradualmente. Uno dei tantissimi da lui truffato. Mi ha azzerato tutti i risparmi, come accaduto a moltissimi altri come me. Gianni Panni di Modena.
---
Condannato da Consob a pagare ben 70.000 euro di multa per mega truffa fatta da sto verminoso, vi assicuro, pure pederasta stupra bambini, di Paolo Barrai. Sul fotovoltaico. Che solo a me, ha portato via 1.400.000 euro, quasi tutto quello che avevo.
http://www.consob.it/main/documenti/hide/afflittivi/pec/mercati/2013/d18579.htm
---
Condannato al carcere in Brasile, otto anni di galera sentenziatissimi. Per pedofilia, furto, truffa, minacce di morte, stalking via internet, riciclaggio di soldi mafiosi, propaganda razzista, propaganda nazifascista. Ecco i links di inizio indagine. Ora vi e' la sentenza. E' scappato da Porto Seguro di notte, in pieno carnevale 2011, per fuggire a processo e galera. Fate voi di che schifoso topo di fogna parliamo quando parliamo di sto colerico ratto criminalissimo che da sempre e' Paolo Barrai.
http://www.portonewsnet.com.br/?mw=noticias&w=2996
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-aqbT4KlYsmw/TcLbvUUpkeI/AAAAAAAAAe4/TiDPLR0LH_U/s1600/barrai+ind-pag01.jpg
http://www.rotadosertao.com/noticia/10516-porto-seguro-policia-investiga-blogueiro-italiano-suspeito-de-estelionato
http://portoseguroagora.blogspot.be/2011/03/porto-seguro-o-blogueiro-italiano-sera.html
http://noticiasdeportoseguro.blogspot.be/2011/03/quem-e-pietro-paolo-barrai.html
---
Condannato al carcere a Milano ad inizio anni 2000. "Il funzionario di Citibank in grossi guai" come da finale del seguente articolo era lui.
http://archiviostorico.corriere.it/2001/febbraio/02/Arrestato_imprenditore_delle_truffe_fiscali_co_7_0102023408.shtml
Cacciato a sberle, poi, da Citibank, e fatto condannare al carcere dalla stessa Citibank.
---
In possesso della tessera di ... tenetevi forte, pls, and stra pls "ORGOGLIO PEDOFILO".
https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/NAMBLA
STO SCHIFOSO DEPRAVATO ... LO DEVO DIRE... IN QUANTO VERO... SODOMIZZA BAMBINI, SODOMIZZA ZINGARELLI DI 10-12 ANNI, CHE E' STO ACCLARATISSIMO PEDERASTA DI PAOLO BARRAI, RAGLIA SPESSISSIMO IN PRIVATO: "NEL LATIN AMERICA CHE TANTO AMO, E' FACILE FARE SESSO CON RAGAZZINI DI 10-14 ANNI... TANTE BAMBINE DI 12-14 ANNI RIMANGONO IN CINTA.. QUINDI, IO SCOPO I BAMBINI, BEVO IL LORO PRIMO SPERMA... SON PEDOFILO E ME NE VANTO". HO SENTITO QUESTI SUOI DISCORSI DA VOMITO ANCHE IO, QUANDO VENNE A TROVARCI A MODENA.
(http://ilpunto-borsainvestimenti.blogspot.be/2013/03/lunedi-11-marzo-cena-modena-per-parlare.html)

Ciro Sciacqualaquaglia New York - Naples said...

2
Fa sempre, via bastardo nazista e mafioso Gruppo Berlusconi, che lo proteggere, chiudere i miei Facebook o Google account, in quanto svelo assolute verita' che li imbarazzano. Ma appena mi fara' chiudere anche questo account, ne riapriro' cento. Fra Facebook, Linkedin, Blogger, Google Plus, You Tube, e migliaia e stra migliaia di Blogs.
But let's go ahead now, pls, let's go ahead.
Fece comprare il Bitcoins a 700 dollari, dicendo che in un baleno sarebbe andato a 70.000, ed ora vale 200 dollari circa.
( http://ilpunto-borsainvestimenti.blogspot.be/2014/03/bitcoin-con-giacomo-zucco-stiamo-ridendo.html)
Fece comprare Ftse Mib ragliando che sarebbe andanto subito a 40.000, ma lo stesso perse il 30% in un baleno.
( http://ilpunto-borsainvestimenti.blogspot.be/2015/07/la-borsa-italiana-e-sui-massimi.html )
Fece comprare il Gas Naturale a 12 $ nel 2008 e lo stesso precipito' un anno dopo "appena appena" a 3$ ( perdita secca del 80%.. da infarto... fate voi, pls)
http://www.nasdaq.com/markets/natural-gas.aspx?timeframe=10y
Fece vendere il Dow Jones, ragliando che sarebbe crollato a 15.000 ed in un mese lo stesso volo' su a a 18.000.
( http://ilpunto-borsainvestimenti.blogspot.be/2014/10/dow-jones-atteso-in-area-15000.html)
Fece vendere o non sottoscrivere i Btp e da quel momento son divenuti oro misto a platino.
http://archiviostorico.corriere.it/2011/novembre/28/Barrai_dico_dieci_motivi_per_co_8_111128030.shtml
Fece comprare a Mafia, Camorra e Ndrangheta ( suoi veri e soli clienti.. che se ne fregano delle performances, volendo solo lavara capitali assassini) case in Brasile, nel Marzo 2011, e da allora il Real Brasiliano ha perso "solo" il 60% per cento.
http://www.xe.com/currencycharts/?from=BRL&to=EUR
http://www.forexinfo.it/Real-brasiliano-rischia-il-tracollo-tra-crisi-economica-e-politica
Fece comprare l'oro a 1800 dollari, nell'Estate 2011, ed a seguire, lo stesso, e' "solo" precipitato fino a 1160 dollari.
Fece comprare il petrolio a 105 dollari e passa, nella primavera 2014, e lo stesso, e' caduto in un baratro: giu fino a 43 dollari attuali!
Raglio' di "de dollarizzazione", a fine 2011, mentre l'euro valeva 1,40 contro un dollaro, e lo stesso dollaro ha poi guadagnato un 30% e passa contro l'euro.
Ma vi rendete conto di quanto vi sputtanerete in tutto il mondo e per sempre, ad accostarvi a... parole sue.. sto "bevitore di primo sperma di bambini dodicenni", quale il gia' tante volte in galera, verminoso pedofilomosessuale Paolo Barrai di criminalissima Wmo sa Panama e criminalissima Bsi Italia srl di via Socrate 26 a Milano? Scritto per mero vostro bene. Questo e' solo un antipastino su chi e' davvero sto mega truffatore e mega avanzo di galera di Paolo Barrai. Fra poco mi stra scatenero' giorno e notte. A fra non molto. giannipanni@gmx.com

Anonymous said...

http://co.centre.pa.us/centreco/media/upload/SANDUSKY%20WITNESS%20CERTIFICATION%20OF%20ATTORNEY%20GENERAL%20KATHLEEN%20KANE.pdf

Pennsylvania private investigator said...

After reading this post I thought the importances of security and investigation.A proper investigation should be carried out when-ever there needed.